Fantasy Football Trade Question...Need your opinion.

F.A.D.E.D. · Sep 25, 2009

Ok. here's the trade. No PPR. I'm 0-2 and just not very happy with my team. Feel Im weak at WR and I need have decent Depth at RB..

Got McGahee on waivers last week. Im looking to SELL high because he isn't as good as his numbers IMO.

put a couple trades out there and one guy accepted but he said he'll give me til tomorrow to decide if I want to do the trade.

His giving me Braylon Edwards for Mcgahee. (I'm usually not even thinking about playing him)....add to the fact that I just got him off of waivers just a week ago....Like Im getting Braylon for free.

......................

RB's I have....

M. Turner
R. Brown
W. Magahee
L. Washington
R. Williams

Wr's I have....

G Jennings
B. Marshall
T. Ginn
A Bryant
Micheal Clayton

..................................................................

Think I'm going to pull the trigger on this one. 90% of the weeks I'm not even thinking about starting McGahee....ALSO, are starting lineup is FLEX....so its QB, RB, WR,WR, RB/WR, TE, D, K.

Think it's a good move guys? I think braylon will step it up and Browns should be throwin a lot this yr.

ECS · Sep 25, 2009

I was going to say yes until I saw the flex WR/RB, seems to me that you'd always want a RB in that spot, and Id rather go with

Turner, Brown, McGahee than

Jennings, Marshall, Edwards

Not to mention, he plays for the browns and has maybe the worst offense in the league behind him. I say no deal

F.A.D.E.D. · Sep 25, 2009

But other than when either Ronnie or Turner has a bye....Mcgahee aint going to see playing time................

F.A.D.E.D. · Sep 25, 2009

more opinions please....anyone seeing what I'm saying??

Gonzo · Sep 25, 2009

i think you might be selling yourself short right now. mcgahee might not keep putting up these points, but you should get something better than edwards at the moment.

gelo24 · Sep 25, 2009

Since this league is no PPR, I think that McGahee will put up much better numbers than Edwards since he is getting the goalline touches for Baltimore. Edwards had only 3 TDs all of last season and hasn't done anything spectacular to start this year. I agree with your idea of trading McGahee, but he has another good matchup this week against the Browns and I just really don't like Edwards since their offense is pathetic. Really tough call, but I think I would look for more than Edwards and would also scan the waiver wire for someone like Sims-Walker or Laurent Robinson rather than trade McGahee away.

FairWarning · Sep 25, 2009

Keep McGahee and start him. Not only does Braylon have to step it up, so does Quinn. Browns also play in a division with all very good d's. If you want a receiver, grab Johnny Knox.